Domanda di colloquio
Colloquio per Software Engineer

IBMPuzzle: How do you weight an elephant without using a weigh machine?
Risposte di colloquio
46 risposte
Not quite. The volume of the water is not the same as the weight of the elephant. You'd have to estimate the density of an elephant and multiply that by the volume of the water to get the mass, then multiply that by the acceleration due to gravity in water system (SI, English Customary, etc.) you're using. Luckily, mammals are mostly water (humans are around 70% water on average), so about 2/3 of the weight of the elephant would be equivalent to the weight of the water displaced. So you would have to estimate how dense the rest of the elephant is (since it'd be minerals and such, I'd say it's more dense than water) and follow the steps described above.
Kyle su
Simple answer : Use a beam balance . Put elephant on one side and start throwing weights on the other side . When the beam is balanced you got the weight of the elephant equal to the sum of weights on the other !
MG su
As it is not specified that the International System of Units must be used, define the Elephant unit (E) as the weight of your elephant. Your elephant then weights exactly 1E.
Wouzz su
Apply a known force to the elephant and measure the acceleration. Use physics to deduce the mass.
Stuart su
it sounds like you all are trying to determine whether an elephant is a witch (Monty Python reference). Instead of dealing with the whole mess of a wet elephant, why not use other pneumatic tools like an inflatable platform, an air pump, and a pressure sensor. See how much air pressure is required to lift the elephant.
pt su
Just ask him...
Overthinker su
Possible answers: 1. Zero. Take the elephant to space. The weight = 0. 2. I can guess it to around 150 kg ( there is fat person who lives next door and we call him an elephant his weight is 150 kg)
adityaeipl su
I got asked this question. But the water displacement has gotten old. They prompted me for another answer. I said you measure the elephant and find out its volume in cubic meters. Then weigh its leg and measure it. Lets say the leg weighs 20 kgs and has a volume of 20 cubic metres. Then, each cubic metre weighs 1 kg. So if the total volume of elephant is 350 cubic meters, it will weigh 300 cubic metres.
Sharanya su
My experience is this, you don't have to have a perfectly correct answer. The goal of the question is to see if you can think around a problem. Besides elephants, I have heard 747's and aircraft carriers used as the object. A good answer shows that you thought of an alternate way of measurement, so the water displacement and pressure sensor ideas work. PS, if they ask you to weigh a 747, I would answer "Land it on an aircraft carrier and measure the additional water displacement!"
EP su
Kyle I have to disagree with you. According to Buoyancy principle: Any object, wholly or partially immersed in a fluid, is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the fluid displaced by the object. So if you calculate the displaced fluid weight, which is quite easy in water as it is very close or equal to 1kg/L, you can get very close to the real weight of the elephant.
Fernando su
one "weight"(s) by putting a weight on it
massive weight on my mind su
by using first clas lever. keep an elephant at known distance from the fulcrum; make the effort distance long enough that your weight balances the weight of an elephant; by using the formula load*load distance = effor*effortdistance( principle of lever) you already know load distance, effort distance and effort now you can calculate load, which is nothing but elephan'ts weight
Naresh su
use SEE SAW put elephant on one side and on other side some men when it get balanced weighs the men
asad su
Elephants DO float, even in fresh water. They're blubbery.
Sami su
By using the momentum conservation law, First I find a heavy enough object mith exact mass of m1 and then throw it with speed V1 to the elephant which is standing on a frictionless surface like ice or on plate with wheels under it to reduce the friction. after they meet, the elephant will move. and the object will change its direction and speed. Then I calculate the speed and direction of elephant and reflecting object, and finally I solve the vector equation below: m.v1=m.v2+M.V v1=vector of initial speed of object v2=vector of final speed of object M=elephant mass V=vector of elephant speed
Pooya su
note that the answer above is referenced to the question on THIS page which has been transcribed wrongly from the "home page" question (the "t" has been added)
massive weight on my mind su
I would ask if it was an Indian elephant or an African elephant.
Monty su
I would solicit bids and then subcontract the task to a reputable, costeffective elephant weight service vendor, and let THEM decide the best approach.They can use a weigh machine or use any other method that does not require ME to use a weigh machine. The question (and answer) are no different than any other variation of, "How do you accomplish a task when you don't have the needed resources?"
Sandy su
You could just put a boat in water, measure displacement. Then put the elephant in the boat and take the difference. The displacement is going to equal mass as long as it's floating so you're good in a boat. Kyle was right that if you just threw an elephant in a pool, you would have you figure out density and all that.
Matt su
I would use a see saw to weight my elephant. Using my weight (212 lbs in work wear), move the elephant until we balance, and then compare my distance to the pivot point to Clancy's distance to the pivot. (I named my elephant Clancy). The hardest part... finding a see saw strong enough to hold Clancy.
AZ su
Use a pool > calculate the volume of water of the pool and the water level, put the elephant in the pool, take note of the level after the elephant after it is in the pool. By Archimedes principle, the volume of water dislocated is the same as the weight. So the weight of the elephant is the same as the difference in water volume.
Fernando su
Isn't that just an improvised "weighing machine"?
Ben su
Take heavy weight gym dumbells keep start hanging with the one end of the rope an the other end to elephant and the rope goes over the pully,keep adding weight till elephant gets lifted
Rishabh su
esimate the answer to certain range and put it on a boat and if the boat shrinks it is more than the estimate weight else less else use F=MA forumula apply certain force and the calculate acceleration and then mass
rahul su
OK guys i take a boat which can carry more than a load of an elephant i keep the elephant in that boat [ there fore designed load = load of elephant+ X load] i will add some more load by boarding some swimmers one by one into boat if it starts sinking it means it reached designed load [designed load
sam su
By allowing him to sit on us
Ayush su
Fernando,Your answer is really very wierd. First of all: rise in level of water will be equal to elephant's volume not weight. There is a vast difference in volume and weight. Second: if you think that you will estimate it's density to calculate it's weight then it will be a wierd thing because you will never be able to guess it right. Third: rise in level of water of pool will indicate the volume of submerged part of elephant and not whole elephant. If you think that you will submerge whole elephant then obviously you are killing it .So your answer is scientifically and economically wrong. I might suggest that you should take a help of a strong boat to determine elephant weight. take the boat in water and elephant on the boat.the boat will obviously sink a little.mark the level. now get elephant off the boat and put some weights on the boat till it reaches same level. now measure the weights and you will get the weight of elephant THANK YOU
rizviz su
by counting the elephant letters, 8 letters is the answer.
VRL.Purnima su
You don’t need a weigh machine to weight the elephant. The elephant is the weight
Anonimo su
Check the elephant has ever been weighed in near past and rely on that data
Anonimo su
we can use a machine to measure its mass. Traditional weighing scale(WHICH MEASURES MASS NOT WEIGHT) would do the job
Anonimo su
By waiting
SIINDHU su
First I'll measure the volume of a large cubical pool filled with water then I'll let the Elephant get inside of it. As the Elephant gets in it spills out some water off the pool. Now after the Elephant goes out the water level of the pool would have reduced. So, now Weight of Elephant = Volume of water before  Volume of water after Elephant got in the pool.
Ayushee Priyadarshini su
Put the elephant onto a large boat, and mark the water level that the boat sinks to. Then, take the elephant out and put a bunch of marked weights onto the boat until it reaches the same water level. Add up the masses of the weights to get the weight of the elephant.
Shubam Naik su
I feel to seen an elephant is weight is very heavy.
Anonimo su
Simply ask the Elephant what his weight is
Mir su
if we can approximate animal body density. we can multiply it with the volume of the elephant. Rho * V = mass Weight = Mass * Gravity
Anonimo su
One method would be to measure a container first, enter elephant and then measure the container. Question says to measure the 'elephant' without a measuring scale.
mih ash su
dip that elephant in medium size water pool....as the Archimedies principle.... the weight of elephant is equal to weight of the water that exist...
srinivas su
Just find a person having a bad day and weigh him/her, help that person feel better, then weigh him/her again. The difference is the weight of the elephant you removed off his/her back. Works for monkeys too.
DaveH su
Archimedes Law of the Lever states: Magnitudes are in equilibrium at distances reciprocally proportional to their weights. "Give me a place to stand on, and I will move the Earth."
ERIC su
I would say bring a female elephant and let them enjoy life..
chodobhagat su
Hmm, I think Kyle is right... and so are you when you say "Any object, wholly or partially immersed in a fluid, is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the fluid displaced by the object". IMHO elephants don't float...
Wouzz su
Actually Kyle is right. If we put something in the water, such as an sealed box with a ten pound weight inside (does not float), it will displace a proportionate amount of water. However, if we fill it up with a 50 pound weight, the same amount of water will be displaced, however. Fernando, you are using the Buoyancy principle. The Buoyancy principle is meant for objects that float (hence the word buoyancyit means pressure to keep afloat). As Wouzz said, elephants don't float.
The Nav su
elevate the elephant to height "h". it will have potential energy of "U=mgh". hurl the elephant into a well which is vacumed well to avoid friction. at the end of the well, there is a pool of water with exact mass of " m' " and temprature of T1. after elephant reaches the pool he will give all of his energy to water causing water to become warmer Q=U. so mgh=m'c(T2T1) with knowing g,h,m',c,T1 and T2 m can be calculated easily.
Pooya su
place elephant on an iron plate and move it horizontally with steady speed v. and pass them through a constant magnetic field of B. change B untill the elephant start to move upward. read B and V. F=V x B is the force of magnetic field ( x denotes vector multiplication) which is now equal to weght force W=mg. knowing g the gravity constant, solve m.
Pooya su