Big Ambitions? Or total Hubris? - Recensione dipendente - Mechanical Design Engineer presso Atomic Machines

2,0
28 lug 2023
Consiglia
Gradimento del CEO
Pronostico commerciale

Vantaggi

Credit where credit is due: This company has some of the best resources of any startup I've seen, machine shop, instrumentation, tools. you want it they've got it. This company has some of the smartest, coolest, most talented engineers I have had the privilege of working with, and I'd happily work with any of them again. Food! there's very regular events with food and socializing and that's nice. There's cool challenging science problems to solve, which is a lot of fun. Jeff, the CEO, can sell ice to an Eskimo, and that's exactly what you want from a CEO. Klaus, the CTO is a brilliant engineer, and I'd trust him any day to design an excellent robot.

Svantaggi

97% of hardware startups fail, because hardware development is extremely difficult. It's a complex multi-physics problem that most people fail to fully comprehend at the onset of a project; this company is no different. It was founded by a person with zero ground level hands on industry experience in manufacturing, robotics, or semiconductors, and yet those are the very three industries it seeks to revolutionize. In fact, there's no IP that validates the possibility of the long term vision of the company, it's rooted in technologist musings about the potential of nanotechnology (read "Radical Abundance" or "There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom"). It's as if Jules Verne had gone to the Wright brothers and said " you boys better seal this thing up, because it's going to the moon some day". Yes, a very smart person conceived of the possibility of this seemingly impossible thing, but they didn't work out how to get there or make it a viable business. That is one of the primary frustrations of an engineer working here: you will constantly be forced to make design choices in service of the 'long term vision' , but there is no high level system diagram, no tech development roadmap to the end goal, or really even a well thought out next step for the system; all due to the fact that the vision for the company had no experiential backing to conceive of the technological complexity that it would actually take to build such a thing. The entire company is based on thought experiments, and as smart as they are, the leaders of this company are much much more confident than they are intelligent. Confidence is a shrewd salesman, caution is a prudent planner. No one flew to the moon on confidence or thought experiments, they flew on the wings of hundreds of thousands of person-hours of cautious de-risking, and sound scientific evidence. Do you like working nights and weekends? probably not, you will here. Do you like your project being dictated to you to manage the anxiety of someone who doesn't actually understand the problems? probably not. you will here. do you like plastic smiles that will drop you the second you stop being useful? probably not. that's par for the course. If you find yourself reading this, and are still compelled to apply for a job, I implore you: ask as many questions as you can. what is their target market? who is the typical customer? what's the minimum viable product? what's the shortest path to market? what's the total addressable market? What is the core defensible IP that enables the long term vision? BASIC business questions. In addition to this, I would advise on you to record any conversations you have in interviews. A common tactic when pitching at Atomic is 'word soup' . Answering valid questions with rapid multi minute long winded nonsensical answers that have just enough valid points to make you think you agree, but if you slow it down, and think about every point made, it usually falls apart. Question and diligently record everything in the interview process, and you might not have the wool pulled over your eyes. In general, if you are really smart/talented and want a job where you can keep your head down and enjoy great pay and sweet benefits, go for it. But they will work you to the bone, and that gravy train is likely going to come to a hard stop as the company continues to miss deadlines due to fundamental misunderstandings of how to be successful in hardware.

avatar
Risposta di Atomic Machines
1y
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts. We truly value all feedback, as it helps us grow as a company. While we respect your perspective, we fundamentally disagree with your views on what it takes to be successful and how industries are disrupted. It’s clear that Atomic Machines, like many startups, may not be the right fit for everyone, and we understand that. Building a startup is no small task, and the fast-paced, evolving environment can certainly be challenging. This is part of creating something new in a rapidly changing industry. While it can be demanding, we firmly believe the rewards of innovation and growth are worth the effort. We also take pride in fostering a transparent and engaging interview experience. We encourage candidates to ask thoughtful and in-depth technical questions to ensure that both sides have a clear understanding of the challenges and opportunities ahead. We believe that open dialogue during interviews is essential for both assessing fit and ensuring that candidates have all the information they need. We aim to provide clear and honest answers, and we value the curiosity and insight that come from asking tough, detailed questions.

Esplora altre recensioni su Atomic Machines

5,0
6 apr 2026
Dipendente anonimo
Consiglia
Gradimento del CEO
Pronostico commerciale

Vantaggi

First-principles thinking is the default — you'll be pushed to understand why, not just what Genuinely meritocratic; what you deliver matters more than tenure or title The problem sits at the intersection of advanced manufacturing and AI — it's technically as hard as it gets Surrounded by exceptionally high-caliber people every day; the talent bar is real The work matters — you're not optimizing a feed algorithm, you're building something with physical consequence

Svantaggi

Ambiguity is real — no playbook, high tolerance required Expectations are high and the pace is demanding; not for everyone Still building the internal infrastructure needed to scale

1,0
3 mar 2026
Consiglia
Gradimento del CEO
Pronostico commerciale

Vantaggi

They have many talented employees and have interesting projects to work on and solve on a daily basis.

Svantaggi

The company operates very much like an early-stage startup — fast-moving, deadline-driven, and constantly under pressure. While speed can be energizing, the combination of aggressive timelines and tight deadlines often translates into extremely long work hours. Many of the project timelines felt unrealistic from the start, which created a cycle of urgency rather than sustainable execution. What concerned me most before I decided to leave was the pattern I observed within the engineering team. The engineers who were doing the majority of the heavy lifting gradually left, largely due to leadership’s tendency to overpromise, coupled with a lack of appreciation and recognition for the work being done. In addition, the company’s capital burn rate appeared concerning, adding another layer of uncertainty. While the company may ultimately succeed, from my perspective at the time, the risks seemed to outweigh the foundation in place.

3
avatar
Risposta di Atomic Machines
4w
Thank you for taking the time to share such detailed feedback. We’re glad you found the work engaging and the team talented — that’s something we care deeply about. As a fast-growing company, we are continually trying to balance the intensity and urgency that comes with bringing a new disruptive technology into the world while also scaling into a more sustainable pace of execution. Like the many successful startups before us, it is hard to find that perfect equilibrium. We will continue to stretch to achieve more than we thought was possible. We are incredibly proud of and humbled by the contributions of our engineers and all Atomizers have been essential to our success to date and we are continuing to invest in how we better support, develop, and recognize our managers and our team. Creating a respectful and inclusive culture is a top priority for us. We will continue to foster an environment where ideas can be challenged constructively while maintaining trust and mutual respect. There is more work to do, including broadening our representation, and we are excited about the company and culture we have built so far. We appreciate your perspective and wish you the best in your next chapter.
Vedi recensioni per: Utile|Valutazione|Data|Tutto