Taking this Job Stagnated my Career and Made me Unconfident in my Working Abilities - Recensione dipendente - Digital Media Buyer presso WITHIN

1,0
15 mag 2026
Consiglia
Gradimento del CEO
Pronostico commerciale

Vantaggi

- lunch benefit - trauma bonding with your starting class

Svantaggi

What stayed with me most about this job was not the workload itself, but the way the company systematically made employees feel disposable, incompetent, and constantly afraid of failing. This job was the reason I (along with many of my coworkers) moved to NYC after college. I accepted the role believing I was joining a company that wanted to invest in me long term: my position was salaried, included healthcare and 401k benefits, and was framed as the start of a real career path. Instead, on the very first day, my entire cohort was sat down and told that not all of us would “make it through” training, and that the next few months would determine whether we were “worthy” of staying full time. From the beginning, the environment felt less like onboarding and more like a competition built around intimidation. At first, our assignments were centered around learning the work itself. But once employees inevitably quit or were quietly pushed out (something that happened far more often than leadership admitted), the company began placing trainees onto active client accounts due to understaffing. What followed felt like corporate hazing. I was expected to perform at the level of a fully trained employee while simultaneously being excluded from the resources necessary to succeed. I was not allowed to sit with coworkers working on the same accounts, excluded from group chats where project information was shared, and left out of meetings that directly impacted the work I was responsible for producing. It was humiliating and made it impossible to feel like part of the team. At the same time, me and my fellow trainees were assigned responsibilities completely outside the scope of the role and not listed in the job description. This included but not limited to helping build a website despite having no background in web design, locating six-figure budget discrepancies despite not being accountants, or managing complicated client relationship issues without access to the relevant context or communications. People were constantly being evaluated against expectations they had never actually been trained for. What made the environment especially damaging, however, was that there never seemed to be a consistent or transparent standard for success. Some members of my cohort “graduated” from training despite not completing all required assignments, while others were told they were falling behind without receiving clear explanations as to why. When we asked what differentiated successful employees from unsuccessful ones, we were never given direct answers. The goalposts constantly moved, making it feel impossible to ever truly meet expectations. When I was eventually told I was “not on track” to graduate from training, despite already being beyond the original timeline they had communicated, I was informed that one of the reasons was that I asked too many questions about my work and role responsibilities. This was especially ironic because one of the company’s stated core values was “get curious.” When I explained that my questions came from a lack of clarity around expectations and feedback, I was essentially told to accept the dysfunction because “that’s just how the company operates,” despite leadership frequently claiming they welcomed feedback about the program. The reason I am posting about my experience now is due to the severe lasting impact this environment had on my mental health and professional confidence. Even after leaving, I carried intense anxiety into every corporate environment I entered. Every casual manager check-in made my heart race because I was terrified of once again being blindsided and told I was failing despite receiving little or no actionable feedback. I became hesitant to ask coworkers questions out of fear that I would be excluded from opportunities or viewed as incapable. A workplace should help employees grow more confident and collaborative over time; this experience did the opposite. It left me constantly on edge, hypervigilant, and doubtful of my own abilities. I want to be careful not to place the responsibility of my mental health struggles onto one employer. However, I do believe it is important to warn prospective employees - especially those with anxiety, depression, or similar conditions - that this environment can be deeply psychologically damaging. This company has a way of making employees internalize impossible expectations and then blaming them when they inevitably struggle under the weight of inadequate training, inconsistent standards, and exclusionary management practices. Over time, you stop questioning the system and start questioning your own intelligence, work ethic, and self-worth. I genuinely believe this environment would erode almost anyone’s mental health if they stayed long enough. If you're interviewing or considering accepting a job, move forward with caution.

Esplora altre recensioni su WITHIN

5,0
27 ott 2025
Consiglia
Gradimento del CEO
Pronostico commerciale

Vantaggi

- A lot of independence - Not un-reasonable workload - If you have a solution/idea, people will listen - Fantastic office

Svantaggi

- Lots of churn at company - Have to be happy making your own role

1
avatar
Risposta di WITHIN
6mo
Thank you for your review! We're glad to hear you're enjoying the office, the autonomy in your role, and the openness to new ideas. We appreciate your feedback on team changes and the importance of role clarity; these are areas we continue to focus on as we grow. Thanks for being part of the team!
1,0
13 apr 2026
Consiglia
Gradimento del CEO
Pronostico commerciale

Vantaggi

Remote work. Weekly Meal Bonus

Svantaggi

One of the biggest concerns is that many managers are very early in their careers, often with only a few years of experience. While they are energetic and well-intentioned, they generally lack the leadership and client-facing experience needed to effectively support their teams. This becomes particularly noticeable in high-pressure situations or when managing complex client relationships. Team allocation is another issue. Employees are typically assigned to teams without much consideration for their preferences or long-term development goals. This lack of flexibility can make it difficult to build a career path within the company. Work-life balance is also a major drawback. Long hours are the norm, and working late into the night—sometimes until 10 PM, 11 PM, or even midnight—is quite common. The workload is consistently heavy across most teams, and expectations can feel overwhelming, especially without strong managerial support. Additionally, the company appears to have relatively high turnover. There have been reports of significant layoffs in the past, and the cycle of hiring and attrition seems ongoing. This creates a sense of instability and makes it harder for teams to maintain continuity.

2
avatar
Risposta di WITHIN
1mo
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re glad you appreciated the flexibility of remote work and some of the employee benefits offered at WITHIN. We also recognize the concerns you raised around leadership experience, team structure, workload, and long-term sustainability. As we continue to grow, we’re actively investing in manager development and working to improve support, communication, and career pathing across the organization. We appreciate your perspective and wish you the best in your future endeavors.
Vedi recensioni per: Utile|Valutazione|Data|Tutto